Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food review

At a Glance

  • Top 5 Ingredients:
    1. Water Buffalo
    2. Lamb Meal
    3. Chicken Meal
    4. Sweet Potatoes
    5. Peas
  • Type: Dry food
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Calories: 370 kcal/cup
  • Protein: 32%
  • Fat: 18%
  • Fiber: 4%

Taste of the Wild High Prairie Grain-Free Dry Dog Food hits all the hallmarks required from a food to fuel the highly active Border Collie. A grain-free formulation, Taste of the Wild places a high emphasis on excellent quality proteins with its main source being buffalo.

This diet, consistently ranked among the best dog foods for Border Collies, has been enriched through the addition of antioxidant dense foods which are also full of essential vitamins and nutrients. This food is free from grain, corn, wheat, fillers, artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives.

A proprietary blend of supplements which includes probiotics has been added to ensure proper digestion.

Pros

  • Dogs love the taste of this food, licking their bowl clean with every meal.
  • Owners love that Taste of the Wild offers several different adult foods with different protein bases, allowing them to provide their dogs with variety in their diet without sacrificing nutritional quality or experiencing gastrointestinal distress.
  • Dogs previously suffering with gastrointestinal distress found complete relief with a switch to Taste of the Wild High Prairie.
  • Owners report their dogs have softer, shinier, and healthier coats as a result of switching to this diet.
  • Dogs that struggled with itchiness saw greatly improved and hydrated skin when fed a regular diet of Taste of the Wild High Prairie.

Cons

  • In rare instances, some dogs experienced a slight weight gain when fed this diet consistently. This may simply be a matter of the meal size needing to be adjusted to return to a healthy weight.
  • Some dogs disliked the taste of this food. Taste of the Wild offers many different adult options based on other meat proteins. One of these food formulations may be a better fit.
  • Some dogs were unable to process this food well and displayed mild gastrointestinal distress such as nausea, soft stools, and diarrhea. A switch to another Taste of the Wild food based on a different protein may resolve this issue.
  • Some owners express they would prefer a diet that contains some grains, feeling whole grains help their Border Collie to achieve ideal digestion.
  • This diet places a heavy emphasis on potatoes and peas, two ingredients that are the subject of controversy and that may lack in nutritional benefit for dogs.

Eagle Pack Original Adult Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Formula Dry Dog Food review

At a Glance

  • Top 5 Ingredients:
    1. Lamb Meal
    2. Oatmeal
    3. Ground Brown Rice
    4. Dehulled Barley
    5. Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols)
  • Type: Dry food
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Calories: 337 kcal/cup
  • Protein: 23%
  • Fat: 12%
  • Fiber: 4%

Eagle Pack Original Adult Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Formula is a high-quality diet that delivers all of the nutrition the busy Border Collie needs. A well-balanced formulation, this food is rich in antioxidants and omega 3 and 6 fatty acids to ensure a healthy coat and skin and a strong immune system.

Carbohydrates in the form of whole grains are included. These fiber-dense foods encourage healthy digestion, a hallmark of the best dog foods for Border Collies.

This food is manufactured in the United States. It is free from low-quality ingredients such as corn, wheat, by-products, artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives.

Pros

  • Owners relate that their dogs had excellent stool quality when fed a consistent diet of Eagle Pack Original Adult.
  • The flavor of this food is highly pleasing to most dogs. They now eagerly anticipate their every Eagle Pack meal.
  • Owners reported an improvement in digestion in their dogs when fed this diet on a regular basis.
  • Owners feel confident that the ingredients in this diet are high quality, supporting optimal health and wellness in their Border Collies.
  • Most owners share that they feel the price of this food is excellent. They appreciate being able to purchase a food that is such great quality at an affordable price.

Cons

  • Some owners have shared that this food is very difficult to find in their local stores. Thankfully, it can be purchased online, and delivery is available in most areas.
  • A few dogs disliked the taste of this food and would not eat it. Eagle Pack does offer several different adult formulations based on alternative proteins that may be a better choice for some dogs.
  • Some dogs exhibited poor stool quality when fed this diet on a regular basis. This may be due to a food sensitivity or could be the result of a change that was not gradual enough for the dog’s system.
  • A few owners made note that the bag is poor quality and does not allow for re-sealing after opening.
  • A few dogs had difficulty chewing the kibble, finding the outer coating to be too hard. Softening the food with a little warm water or broth may resolve this problem.

Merrick Real Texas Beef + Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Adult Dry Dog Food review

At a Glance

  • Top 5 Ingredients:
    1. Deboned Beef
    2. Lamb Meal
    3. Salmon Meal
    4. Sweet Potatoes
    5. Potatoes
  • Type: Dry food
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Calories: 379 kcal/cup
  • Protein: 34%
  • Fat: 15%
  • Fiber: 3.5%

Merrick Grain-Free Dry Dog Food offers Border Collies the powerhouse punch of nutrition they need to fuel their bodies for optimal performance. A diet that uses deboned beef as its primary protein source, this food is enriched with easily digestible fruits and vegetables which provide added dietary fiber.

Merrick is grain-free. It has been supplemented with the addition of such beneficial ingredients as omega 3 and 6 fatty acids as well as glucosamine and chondroitin to support healthy joints.

One of the best foods for Border Collies today  Merrick offers this active breed all of the nutrients it needs to thrive.

Pros

  • Owners rave that this food has the exceptional flavor their dogs are looking for in their meals. Even picky eaters consume their meals with hearty gusto.
  • Dogs regularly fed Merrick Grain-Free Adult had coats that were soft, shiny, and healthy.
  • Owners like that this diet includes three different types of fat, something they attribute with keeping their dogs’ skin well-hydrated and healthy.
  • Many owners believe this grain-free food offering has helped their dogs to find relief from the symptoms associated with allergies.
  • Owners consistently praise Merrick for offering several different grain-free adult foods that are based on alternative proteins, allowing them to give their dog some variety in their diet.

Cons

  • Some owners express that the kibble pieces in this diet are too small for their dogs. They have concerns that the small morsels may be a choking hazard.
  • Owners of dogs that require moderate amounts of protein recommend selecting another Merrick offering that contains less protein.
  • Some dogs experienced mild gastrointestinal distress including diarrhea, soft stools, and nausea after being fed a steady diet of this Merrick food. This may be as a result of a sensitivity to one of the ingredients or the transition from the old food to the new not occurring gradually enough.
  • Some owners feel the bag is too small for its cost. They would prefer it come in a 24 pound (or larger) size.
  • A few people felt this diet was cost prohibitive.

VICTOR Select Yukon River Canine Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food review

At a Glance

  • Top 5 Ingredients:
    1. Menhaden Fish Meal (source of DHA-Docosahexaenoic Acid)
    2. Peas
    3. Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed Tocopherols)
    4. Garbanzo Beans
    5. Dehydrated Salmon
  • Type: Dry food
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Calories: 390 kcal/cup
  • Protein: 33%
  • Fat: 16%
  • Fiber: 3.8%

VICTOR Select Yukon River is a well-balanced diet that is ideally suited to meet the needs of the active Border Collie. This diet is grain-free, taking fruits and vegetables as its primary carbohydrate source. Its main protein is derived from fish meal, a condensed protein that is rich in omega 3 and 6 fatty acids as well as DHA.

VICTOR’s high-quality food formulation makes it one of the best dog foods for Border Collies today.

Pros

  • Owners love that this diet contains no grains, attributing it with helping their Border Collies to find relief from their allergies.
  • Dogs previously suffering with gastrointestinal distress had better digestion and alleviation from their symptoms when fed a regular diet of VICTOR Select Yukon River Grain-Free.
  • Owners report that their dogs love the taste of this diet, eagerly looking forward to their every meal.
  • Owners are happy to share that their dogs’ coat quality greatly improved when fed this diet on a continuous basis.
  • The inclusion of taurine in this diet is a big plus for owners looking for a high quality food that prioritizes supplementation for heart health.

Cons

  • Several owners expressed that they wish that this VICTOR food offering contained added supplements to support joint health in the Border Collie.
  • A few owners commented that they found this food to be quite expensive.
  • Some owners felt that this diet’s formulation may have changed as their dogs are not doing as well on it as they once were.
  • Some dogs dislike the taste of this food and will not eat it.
  • A few owners shared the food had an off putting smell to it.

American Journey Limited Ingredient Duck & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food review

At a Glance

  • Top 5 Ingredients:
    1. Deboned Duck
    2. Duck Meal
    3. Peas
    4. Sweet Potatoes
    5. Chickpeas
  • Type: Dry food
  • Lifestage: Adult
  • Calories: 324 kcal/cup
  • Protein: 25%
  • Fat: 12%
  • Fiber: 6%

American Journey LID Grain-Free provides both excellent value and nutrition for the Border Collie. A diet based on limited ingredients, this powerhouse food’s first ingredient is deboned duck, a high-quality source of protein.

The carbohydrates in this diet are derived from easily digestible fruits and vegetables. American Journey, one of the best foods for Border Collies, is free from low-quality ingredients such as corn, wheat, soy, by-products, artificial colors, flavors, and preservatives.

The addition of safflower oil and flaxseed enhances the diet’s omega 3 and 6 fatty acids, two important components in achieving a healthy coat and skin.

Pros

  • Dogs that regularly suffered from gastrointestinal distress found relief when fed a regular diet of this food.
  • Owners were pleased by the limited ingredients list of this food, giving them confidence it was the ideal fit for their Border Collies with allergies.
  • Owners reported a decrease in the amount of flatulence their dogs experienced with a switch to American Journey LID Grain-Free.
  • Dogs love the taste of this food, eating their meals heartily and with gusto.
  • Owners noted that dogs that struggled with itchy skin saw improvements in their skin and reduced itchiness when regularly fed American Journey LID Grain-Free.

Cons

  • Some dogs disliked the smell of this food and would not eat it.
  • Some owners felt the suggested serving sizes listed on the packaging are not accurate. Their dogs required far more than the label indicated.
  • In a few instances, owners commented that their bags of food contained a lot of kibble crumbs.
  • Some owners indicate they would prefer to feed a diet that contains some grains. American Journey does offer several adult food formulations with whole grains in their recipe. These may be a better option for some dogs and their owners.
  • A few dogs saw an increase in flatulence when fed this diet consistently.