Playtime is a vital part of your dog’s day, providing physical and mental stimulation to keep them happy and healthy. Most dogs love a traditional squeaky toy, but sometimes as owners, we need some peace. Luckily, there are a lot of great dog toys that don’t squeak which can still provide all the stimulation your dog needs.
The Best Dog Toys That Don’t Squeak2023 Review
Breed Advisor is reader supported! This page contains affiliate links, that at no additional cost to you, may earn a small commission. Find out more here.
The Best Dog Toys That Don’t Squeak
Editor's Choice
Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy- Best for active dogs
- Rubber material for extra bounce
- Perfect for games of fetch
Runner Up
Bones & Chews Made in USA Cotton Rope with Bones Dog Toy- Best for chewing
- Rope and bone pieces for chewing
- Suitable for average chewers
Also Good
KONG Classic Dog Toy- Best for treat dispensing
- Suitable for soft and hard treats
- Perfect for average chewers
More Detailed Non-Squeaky Dog Toy Reviews
Ann-Marie Sharpe
Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy review
Features
- Best for active dogs
- Rubber material for extra bounce
- Perfect for games of fetch
Ann-Marie Sharpe
The Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy is one of the best dog toys that don’t squeak, especially for active dogs! These balls come in a pack of 2 and are extra bouncy, making them fantastic for games of fetch. They’re brightly colored to prevent you from losing them, even when you’re playing outside, which I found particularly handy.
These balls even float, so your dog can make the most of exploring the outdoors. With no squeaker in sight and a low price, this toy is a fantastic quiet option. They come in 2 sizes, suitable for small and medium-breed dogs.
As a bonus, these balls are compatible with the Chuckit! Ball Launchers to really amp up your fetch game.
Pros
- Durable and long-lasting, standing up to a fair amount of chewing during playtime
- Float for playtime in the bath or when swimming, which owners said their adventurous dogs enjoyed
- No furry covering, which owners stated makes them safer when chewed and easier to clean
- Quality bounce which makes games more entertaining for both dog and owner
- Fits in the Chuckit! Launcher, but owners state they’re just as fun to play with without the launcher
Cons
- Some owners found very aggressive chewers could destroy the balls quickly
- Some owners felt the balls were smaller than expected for their larger dogs
- Some people found the balls had a strong scent, which despite being a pleasant smell, was overpowering
Ann-Marie Sharpe
Bones & Chews Made in USA Cotton Rope with Bones Dog Toy review
Features
- Best for chewing
- Rope and bone pieces for chewing
- Suitable for average chewers
Ann-Marie Sharpe
The Bones & Chews Made in USA Cotton Rope with Bones Dog Toy is a fantastic no-squeaker dog toy, providing hours of chewing fun. With bones on either end of a strong rope, this is a tug toy and a chew toy in one. It’s suitable for all breeds, provided they are average chewers.
The toy has no squeaker or noise included, so it will provide quiet playtime (chewing noises aside). Best of all for humans, this toy comes at a very reasonable price.
Pros
- Great for both tug of war and chewing, which makes the toy better value for money
- Long-lasting for average chewers, especially when under supervision
- Many owners the combination of both rope and bones really kept their dog’s attention for longer than other toys
- Some owners found this toy helpful for teething puppies, keeping them interested and soothing their sore mouth
- Great for redirecting destructive chewing during training
Cons
- Some owners found that this toy was too heavy and awkward for their small dog to carry and play with
- Not suitable for power chewers, as they can destroy the toy easily
- Bones mean that dogs need to be supervised at all times when chewing this toy
- Some owners found the bones broke easily and more quickly than expected
- The rope section is more prone to destruction than the bone ends, which some owners found frustrating
Ann-Marie Sharpe
KONG Classic Dog Toy review
Features
- Best for treat dispensing
- Suitable for soft and hard treats
- Perfect for average chewers
Ann-Marie Sharpe
The KONG Classic Dog Toy is undoubtedly one of the best toys without a squeaker on the market. It’s been a favorite among dog owners for years due to its versatility and high-quality materials. The KONG can be filled with solid treats or soft spreads, as well as used to play fetch or as a chew toy.
This toy is an absolute favorite in our house with all 3 of my dogs. They all adore their KONGS being filled with soft spreads, and my spaniel loves chewing and playing with her KONG once the treats are gone.
This toy stands up to most average chewers and comes in a wide range of sizes to suit every dog breed. It doesn’t produce any noise and is an excellent option for keeping your dog both quiet and happy while you’re busy. It comes at a great mid-range price.
Pros
- Very long-lasting and durable, making them good value for money and allowing dogs to lay with them for long periods
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning, which owners find useful
- When filled with treats, keeps dogs mentally stimulated and happy for a while, giving owners a break while they’re busy doing other things
- Can be frozen with treats inside to make playtime last even longer, which many owners said their dogs enjoyed
- Most owners said they wouldn’t be without a KONG toy for their dog and that it was a staple in their home
Cons
- Some owners found that this strength of KONG wasn’t suitable for power chewers and that they were able to chew the toy up too easily
- Some owners found their dog was able to get their food out of the toy quickly, meaning playtime didn’t last as long as they’d hoped
- A few owners found that the rubber smell of the KONG was overpowering
Ann-Marie Sharpe
KONG Plush Teddy Bear Dog Toy review
Features
- Best removable squeaker
- Squeaker can be easily removed
- Gives the best of both worlds
Ann-Marie Sharpe
The KONG Plush Teddy Bear Dog Toy is a perfect 2 in 1 option for those who want the option of a squeaking toy for their dog. It has an easily removable squeaker, giving a choice between quiet play and a louder game when you feel like it. This cuddly teddy is great for small to medium dogs who love a plush toy, as I found with my small dogs.
This toy is designed for light chewers. It has a squeaker replacement and no stuffing for extra safety if a game does get rough. At an amazingly low price, I would definitely recommend this toy.
Pros
- Removable squeaker gives the option of both loud and quiet play, making the toy good value for money
- Comes with an extra removable squeaker in case the squeaker gets lost or destroyed, which is very handy
- Many owners found that their small dogs or puppies could carry this toy around and play with it comfortably
- Lots of owners said this is their small dogs favorite toy and that they would recommend it
- Some owners said the toy was more durable than they expected, allowing them to play games of tug
Cons
- Some owners found the toy was smaller than they expected, which they found disappointed
- Not designed for dogs who tend to chew their toys, with some owners finding average or tough chewers destroyed the toy quickly
- Some owners felt that the toy was more suited to small rather than medium dogs, due to the size and strength
- Some owners found the hair on the bear sheds when chewed or played with roughly, which can be an inconvenience
Ann-Marie Sharpe
Hear Doggy Silent Squeaker Chew Guard Flattie Elephant Plush Dog Toy review
Features
- Best ultrasonic squeaker
- Heard by your dog only
- Plush and strong
Ann-Marie Sharpe
The Hear Doggy Silent Squeaker Chew Guard Flattie Elephant Plush Dog Toy keeps both owner and dog happy with an ultrasonic squeaker. The squeaker is out of human hearing range, giving you the silence you need while still giving your dog all of that squeaker fun. I had this toy when my dog was a puppy and it provided a much needed break when she wanted to play all day long.
If your dog loves plush toys but tends to chew a lot, this is the toy for you. It’s a cute plush elephant with reinforced seams and lining for average chewers and rough play. It’s suitable for all breeds and comes at a great mid-range price.
Pros
- Gives dogs all the fun of a squeaker while giving owners peace and quiet, which owners said was a relief
- Can be machine washed for easy cleaning, which is very handy for owners
- Owners stated that this toy stands up to average chewers, lasting even longer with supervision
- Lots of owners found their dog really enjoyed the toy and kept coming back to play with it
- Provides mental and physical stimulation, which owners said kept even fussy dogs entertained
Cons
- Some owners found this toy didn’t stand up to very rough play which they found disappointing given the description
- Many owners felt the toy isn’t designed for big, powerful dogs, as it can be destroyed easily
- Some owners felt unsure that their dog was reacting to the squeaker as they usually would with a squeaking toy
Things to Look for in a Dog Toy That Doesn’t Squeak
Let’s take a look at some things to keep an eye out for when buying a dog toy that doesn’t squeak:
Fit for Purpose
Most importantly, of course, you’re going to want to make sure the toy doesn’t have a squeaker and can encourage quiet play. Take a careful look at the toy’s description, as not all toys state clearly that they include a squeaker.
Entertainment Value
If a toy is silent, it needs to provide entertainment for your dog in other ways. Take your time to find a toy that will provide stimulation for your dog despite the lack of squeaker.
Correct Size and Strength for Your Dog
When buying any dog toy, it’s essential to get the right size and strength of toy for your dog. This ensures they can play with it correctly and that it’s safe for them. For example, a small breed dog with a toy that’s too big for them might not be able to fit in their mouth or carry it around, limiting playtime. Alternatively, a big breed dog with a firm bite may quickly destroy a toy that is too small or not designed for tough chewers.
Quality of Materials
Picking a toy with high-quality materials means it’s more likely to last longer and be safe for your dog.
General Dog Toy Safety Advice
Even the best toys aren’t completely indestructible, so it’s important to keep an eye on your dog during playtime. If a toy breaks or any pieces become detached, you should take it away from your dog for their safety. If you plan to leave your dog alone with a toy, ensure it’s tough and matches their chew strength.
Why You Might Choose a Toy With No Squeaker
I love my dogs dearly, but everybody needs peace sometimes. Whether you’re working from home, trying to get the kids to sleep, taking a phone call, or even just trying to relax, the last thing you need is your dog making a lot of noise. This doesn’t make you a ‘bad dog owner’; it simply means you’re human.
Toys with squeakers can get very annoying very quickly, especially if your dog likes to squeak them repeatedly. This might lead you to look at toys without squeakers, and thankfully there are many great options on the market!
Why Some Dogs May Not Like Squeakers
While most dogs love a squeaky toy, there are some exceptions. Some dogs, particularly if they’re a rescue and have had a difficult past, might find a squeaky toy too loud and startling.
Other dogs may like a squeaker but might find it too stimulating. This means it might excite them too much, causing negative behaviors. Finally, just like humans, dogs have preferences, and some may simply enjoy a quieter toy.
No-Squeaker Dog Toy FAQ
Will your dog be bored with a toy that doesn’t squeak?
Many owners worry that giving their dog a toy with no squeaker will result in them being bored. This is far from the case. There are all sorts of toys with lots of different, exciting features, which means you can find another type of toy that works for your dog.
Conclusion
A toy without a squeaker can give you the quiet that you need while keeping your dog entertained and happy. There are so many choices; you’re bound to find something that works for both you and your dog.
The Best Dog Toys That Don’t Squeak
Editor's Choice
Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Tough Dog Toy- Best for active dogs
- Rubber material for extra bounce
- Perfect for games of fetch
Runner Up
Bones & Chews Made in USA Cotton Rope with Bones Dog Toy- Best for chewing
- Rope and bone pieces for chewing
- Suitable for average chewers
Also Good
KONG Classic Dog Toy- Best for treat dispensing
- Suitable for soft and hard treats
- Perfect for average chewers
