dog wearing a blue harness with adjustable straps
Close-up of a dog wearing a blue harness with adjustable straps

Harness or collar? If you’ve ever stood in the pet store aisle holding one in each hand while your dog tries to steal a squeaky toy off the shelf, you’re in good company. For most pups, the answer comes down to how they walk. If your dog strolls along beside you like a perfect little gentleman, a collar can work just fine. If they pull like they’re auditioning for a sled team, have a delicate airway or have a sneaky Houdini streak, a well-fitted harness is usually the kinder, safer pick.

There’s no single right answer in the harness vs collar debate, because your dog’s breed, size and build all play a part, and plenty of pet parents happily use both. We’d always rather start with the floof in front of you than with one rule for every dog.

Collars: Advantages and Considerations

You can’t beat a collar for keeping your dog’s ID tags on, and it slips on and off in seconds, even with a wriggly pup doing the happy dance at the door. If your dog already trots nicely beside you, that direct connection can make walks feel easy and relaxed.

Collars get tricky if your dog pulls. If your beloved goblin objects to the existence of squirrels, cats, motorbikes and the occasional delivery driver, every lunge to the end of the leash sends all that force straight into their neck, and over time that can lead to choking or breathing trouble. So if your best friend still drags you down the street like they’re late for a very important meeting, keep the collar for their tags and clip the leash somewhere else.

dog wearing a bright orange collar with a metal buckle
Close-up of a dog wearing a bright orange collar with a metal buckle

Harnesses: Advantages and Considerations

With a harness, you take the pressure off your dog’s throat and spread it across their sturdy chest instead, which is safer and comfier for your pooch. A snug fit also makes it much harder for your little escape artist to wriggle free, so you’ll breathe easier on busy streets.

If you’ve got a big, strong puller, there’s one small catch. Some dogs throw their whole body weight into the straps, and suddenly you’re the one being walked! That doesn’t mean a harness is out. You’ll just get the best results when training and gear work together.

And if you and your speed demon are outdoor fans, give joring a try. Your dog pulls you along on skis, a bike or a scooter, and it’s an awesome way to burn off all that energy while you stay in control. Just know that a regular walking harness won’t cut it, and could actually be dangerous. For joring, your dog needs a proper pulling harness that spreads the load safely across their whole body, and the right design depending on the activity.

Bikejoring with a proper pulling harness
Bikejoring with a proper pulling harness

Breed and Dog-Type Considerations

Flat-Faced Breeds

If you share your couch with a snorty little French bulldog, pug or boxer, you already know those adorable squished faces come with shorter airways (vets call these breeds brachycephalic). That’s why a harness is the comfiest choice for their walks, because it keeps the pressure off their throat. The same goes for car rides, so if your Frenchie rides in a car seat, clip the seat tether to a well-fitted harness with a wide chest plate, never a collar, because a sudden stop could put all that force on their neck. Set the tether so your dog can sit and lie down comfortably without reaching the floor or another seat.

Narrow-Headed Breeds

Greyhounds and whippets are the masters of the great escape. Their slim heads are often narrower than their necks, so with one quick step backward, they can slip right out of a standard collar. That’s exactly what martingales and sighthound collars are designed for. When your dog pulls back, a martingale tightens just enough to stop them slipping free, and a sighthound collar’s extra width sits comfortably on that long, elegant neck. A well-fitted harness is another great option for walks.

Small and Delicate Breeds

If your pup fits in a handbag, their delicate little neck feels even a gentle tug much more than a big dog’s would. Toy breeds like Yorkies, Pomeranians and Chihuahuas are also prone to tracheal collapse (when the windpipe weakens and flattens), so pressure on their throat can set off that telltale honking cough. With a harness, you move the leash pressure to their sturdier chest, while a light collar holds their tags.

Puppies

When you’re weighing up a harness vs collar for puppy walks, a harness is often the gentler choice while your little one learns their leash manners, since puppies love to lunge, tug and pounce on every leaf in sight. Keep a collar on for ID, too. Puppies grow ridiculously fast, so check the fit of both every week or two and adjust or size up as needed.

When Using Both Makes Sense

Your dog doesn’t have to pick a team! They can wear a collar for ID and a harness for walks, so their tags are always on and their throat stays protected on outings. Just take the harness off once you’re home.

Here’s a trick most pet parents never think of. If you’re walking a powerful dog, clip a double-ended lead to both the collar and the harness. You get a steadying point at the collar, while the harness takes the full force of every pull, so their neck doesn’t have to.

K9 Sport Sack Kolossus
Black Labrador wearing an orange collar on a rocky mountain trail
Black Labrador wearing an orange collar on a rocky mountain trail

Getting the Fit, Sizing and Construction Right

You could buy the cutest harness in the world, but it won’t do your dog any favors if it doesn’t fit. If their collar’s too loose, your clever little escapee can back right out of it, and if it’s too tight, it rubs and pinches like a pair of jeans after Thanksgiving dinner. You’re aiming for two fingers’ worth of wiggle room under the collar and every harness strap. When you try a harness on, check that it sits snugly without digging in behind the front legs, with a nice wide chest plate to spread the pressure.

At home, have a quick look around for anything your dog’s collar could catch on. Crate wire is the big one, but a chair leg or cabinet handle can snag a collar too and turn a lazy afternoon into a choking scare. So slip the collar off before crate time, and your pup can snooze in peace.

When you’re shopping, give the gear a good once-over. You want sturdy buckles, strong stitching, solid leash rings and straps that adjust to your dog’s one-of-a-kind shape (wonky, chunky or noodle-thin, we love them all). If you’re after something as cute as it is tough, check out Pink Papyrus for gorgeous collars and harnesses, including a whole collection of no-pull harnesses. Their collars are fully adjustable and come in sizes from teeny toy breeds right up to big, lovable lugs.

Once your dog’s all kitted out, keep an eye on them for the first few walks. Watch how they move and breathe, and when you get home, run your hands over the spots where the straps sit to check for rubbing. From those little check-ins, you’ll soon know whether you’ve nailed the fit, and you can keep adjusting as your best friend grows, learns and gets up to new mischief.

 

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch my dog from a harness to a collar once they stop pulling?

Yes, once your dog reliably walks on a loose leash, a collar can work for walks. If the pulling creeps back in during a teenage growth spurt or somewhere extra exciting, go back to the harness until training catches up.

Can my dog wear their collar around the house?

Yes, a light, comfy collar with their tags can stay on at home, so your dog has ID if a door ever opens at the wrong moment. Just slip it off for crate time, since it can catch on the wire.